I want to change my signup preferences, how do I do this? Megan February 13, 2019 22:33 Please update your preferences here: Update Your Mystery Club/Surprise Topper Club Profile Related articles I would like to cancel my Topper Club subscription. How do I switch to a different Topper Club? Can I signup for a Free Topper Club Trial more than once? Can I return a Topper Club order? I ordered other items at the same time I signed up for a club, and those have arrived. Where is my topper? Comments 0 comments Please sign in to leave a comment.